Assessment of the log smuggling causes in Caspian forests, north of Iran

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Forestry Department, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Guilan, Sowmeh Sara, 1144, Guilan, Iran

10.22124/cjes.2022.5553

Abstract

Undoubtedly, log smuggling is one of the most significant factors in quantitative and qualitative reduction of the Caspian forests in north of Iran, while it has received less attention in forest studies. This study was conducted to identify the causes of log smuggling in Guilan Province, Iran. A team of 24 experts from Forest Protection Department, Natural Resources and Watershed Management Organization, Guilan Province was selected, and the study was carried out in three phases by questionnaire and Delphi method. According to the frequency of responses to the first open-ended question in the first stage of Delphi method, number of 24 various specialists’ ideas were identified as the causes of log smuggling. Greed of profiteers, unemployment and the need for income especially among young people, lack of planning in each forest area, poverty in forest communities, easy access to forest areas through forest roads, and closure of forestry plans had the highest frequency among responses. Based on the results from phase two of Delphi method, unemployment and the need for income especially among young people was the notable cause of log smuggling. Systematic corruption, greed of profiteers, poverty in forest communities, failure to deal effectively with log smuggling agents, buying and selling smuggled wood without any trouble are ranked second to sixth, respectively. The Kendall's W test showed no concordance between experts on the questions in relation to the comparison between the ranks among the variables. The results of the tests also showed that the “unemployment and the need for income especially among young people” factor was the first rank, while the “timber industry dependency on certain types of wood” was the last one. The summary of interviewee's opinions after the Kendall's W test illustrated that the most principle log smuggling causes are as follows: unemployment and the need for income especially among young people (94%), systematic corruption (89%), greed of profiteers (86%), and poverty in forest communities (84%), and failure to deal effectively with log smuggling agents (82%). By identifying the factors affecting log smuggling, the necessity of using a strategy to deal with these factors in Guilan Province is felt more than ever.

Keywords

References

  1. Afrand, H, Hasanzad-Navroudi, I, & Naghdi, R 2012, Detecting illegal logging hotspots using GIS and planning to prevent it, Police Management Studies Quarterly, 7: 528-548n(In Persian).

    Alemagi, D, & Kozak, RA 2010, Illegal logging in Cameroon: Causes and the path forward. Forest Policy and Economics, 12: 554-561.

    Bayat-kashkouli, A, & Mehmandoust, M 2016, The study of production, employment and trade in wood industry of Iran, Journal of Wood and Forest and Technology, 24: 143-159, (In Persian).

     Bouriaud, L 2005, Causes of illegal logging in Central and Eastern Europe. Small-scale Forest Economics, Management and Policy, 4(3):269-291.

    Callister, DJ 1999, Corrupt and illegal activities in the forestry sector, World Bank Press, pp. 11-38.

    Contreras-Hermosilla, A 2001, Markets for forest conservation: illegal forest activities in the Asia Pacific Rim, Forest trends, Washington DC, USA, pp. 29-117.

    Contreras-Hermosilla, A 2002, Policy and legal options to improve law compliance in the forest sector, reforming government policies and the fight against forest crime, FAO, Rome, Italy, pp. 43-91.

    Daliri, H 2016, Investigating Unemployment Invariability Hypothesis in Iran's Provinces. Economical Modeling, 10(35):23-45.

    Hosseini, S, Oladi, J, & Amir-nejad, H 2015, The identification and customization of IUCN and CIFOR criteria and indicators for the sustainable management of national parks. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 23: 743-756, (In Persian).

    Inoguchi, A, Soriaga, R, & Walpole, P 2005, Approaches to controlling illegal forest activities: Considerations from Southeast Asia, 104 p.

    Ji, Y, Ranjan, R & Truong, C 2018, Determinants of illegal logging in Indonesia: An empirical analysis for the period 1996–2010. Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 37(2):197-220.

    Kaimowitz, D 2003, Forest law enforcement and rural livelihoods, international forestry review, 5: 199-210.

    Kananian, M 2004, Socio-economic development of forest villages, MSc. Dissertation, Faculty of Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran, 163 p. (In Persian).

    Karsenty, A 2003, Underlying causes of the rapid expansion of illegal exploitation of tropical timber. International Forestry Review, 5(3):236-239.

    Kumar, J, & Agarwal, RG 2016, Design and development of electronic tree surveillance system for detection of illegal wood cutting, PhD Dissertation, Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology, formerly Thapar University, Punjab, India, 185 p.

    Lawrence NW 1999, Social research methods: qualitative and quantitative approaches, Allyn and Bacon Co., pp. 320-608.

    Miller, F, Taylor, R, & White, G 2006, Keep it legal, best practices for keeping illegally harvested timber out of your supply chain, WWF, Global Forest and Trade Network, pp. 203-318.

    1. Mirakhorlou, K, & Akhavan, R 2008, Investigation on boundary changes of northern forests of Iran using remotely sensed data, Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 16(1):148-139, (In Persian).

    Mohammadi-Khoramabadi, A, Talebi, AA & Zwakhals, K 2013, A study of the subfamily Pimplinae (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) in the north of Iran, with eleven new species records, Entomofauna, 34(2), 29-56.

    Moayeri, MH, Barani, H, Shahraki, MR, & Behmanesh, B 2013, Investigating the type and amount of utilization of forest resources by rural people in marginal villages (Case study: Hezar-jarib region, Mazandaran Province), Iranian Journal of Forest, 5: 151-160, (In Persian).

    Mukul, SA, & Quazi, SA 2009, Communities in conservation: changing protected area management and enhanced conservation in Bangladesh, FAO, pp. 143-159.

    Mukul, SA, Manzoor-rashid, AZM, Uddin, MB, & Herbohn, JL 2013, Efficacy of forest law enforcement and incentive based conservation to prevent illegal logging in developing countries: experience from Bangladesh, Earth System Governance, Tokyo, pp. 1-14.

    Nourzad Moghaddam, M, Shamekhi, T, Etemad, V, & Avatefi-hemmat, M 2014, Firewood consumption by rural households in upland of the Caspian forests in the northern Iran and related factors (Case study: Upland villages in southern parts of Kheyrud Forest), Iranian Journal of Forest, 6: 113-125 (In Persian).  

    Obidzinski, K, Andrianto, A, & Wijaya, C 2006, Timber smuggling in Indonesia, critical or overstated problem? Forest governance lessons from Kalimantan, Thailand, pp. 143-159.

    Rezvani, M, & Hashemzadeh, F 2014, Investigating the effective factors on forest degradation and impact of removing livestock from district 14 of the northern forests of Iran: An environmental and economic perspective (Fuman, Iran). Journal of Wood and Forest Science and Technology, 20: 125-138 (In Persian).  

    Richards, M, Wells, A, Del Gatto, F, Contreras-Hermosilla, A, & Pommier, D 2003, Impacts of illegality and barriers to legality: a diagnostic analysis of illegal logging in Honduras and Nicaragua. International Forestry Review, 5(3):282-292.

    Shoeibi, SH, Heshmat-alvaezin, SM, Shamekhi, T, & Amiri, S 2010, Impact of wood import tariff on illegal wood logging in northern Caspian forests. Iranian Journal of Forest, 2: 13-24 (In Persian).    

    Tacconi, L 2007, Illegal logging: law enforcement, livelihoods and the timber trade. Earthscan, London, UK, 258 p.

    Tacconi, L, Boscolo, M, & Brack, D 2003, National and international policies to control illegal forest activities - a report prepared for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Government of Japan. Center for International Forestry Research, Indonesia, 177 p.

    Tacconi, L, Obidzinski, K & Agung, F 2004, Learning lessons to promote forest certification and control illegal logging in Indonesia. Center for International Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia, 209 p.

Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences
Volume 20, Issue 2
April 2022
Pages 243-251

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics